baseball teammates after a home run | Collage and Wood

15+ Baseball Senior Gifts [Last Time Under the Lights]

It's that time of year again: time for the seniors on the team to be recognized and celebrated.

Baseball Senior Night.

Customize this poster with your team colors, team name, and school name and of course, your baseball player's jersey number and pictures!

This is usually their last home game under the lights, so it's a special night for them and your family members.

If you're looking for some ideas on senior baseball gifts, you've come to the right place.

As a handmade seller, I love sharing Senior Night gift ideas available from other Etsy shops - and of course, handmade sports gifts!

In this article, we have everything from baseball-themed room decor to unique gift ideas that will make this night even more memorable.

Don't forget the posters to promote the big game!

Keep reading for more information, and don't forget to check out our Senior Night FAQ section below!

Senior Night can be as simple or in-depth as you'd like it to be. But it's a chance to


It varies depending on the school, but typically there is a Senior Night ceremony where each player is honored and given a gift.

The gifts can be anything from a plaque or trophy to a simple gift certificate.

After the Senior Night ceremony, the seniors traditionally play one last home game for their school.


Celebrate all of the baseball wisdom your coach shared with one of these thoughtful baseball gift ideas.

I found this end of baseball gifts idea for your coach on Etsy: a custom home plate with the player names.

Senior Night is also a great time to show appreciation for your coach with a baseball gift like this keepsake from WorkbenchCustoms from Etsy.


Here are some great ideas that are sure to score a home run!


We've been making senior year collages since 2013. Like this #5 collage.Our custom photo collage gifts are a show stopper and a conversation starter that you will enjoy for years! Shop now at #8 collage.
We can make a #gift -13 #senior - 7 #Baseball - 19 and all jersey number combinations!  We make every number and letter and arrange your photos in a fun way that your baseball player will love.



Gift cards and practical items are sure to be a hit.

Whatever your budget, there are plenty of great gift ideas for the baseball lover in your life.

So get creative and show your love for America's pastime with a thoughtful and unique gift.

The perfect gifts for the baseball fan in your life

Custom gifts your best friend will love: hand painted or hand carved personalized bats. Find these at JCSDesigns shop on Etsy.

A room that's decorated with baseball decorations is the perfect place to spend time when he's in need of some relaxation.

Here are some ideas to get you started.

First, consider hanging posters of your favorite players or teams. You can also frame jerseys or autographed balls.

If you want to get really creative, paint murals of stadiums or players on your walls.

Another fun idea is to gather up photos about his favorite moments in baseball and turn it into a collage.

Whatever you do, make sure the room reflects your player's passion for the game!

Frequently Asked Questions About Baseball Gifts

Senior Night is the perfect time to give baseball themed team gifts. Find this glove lamp at MirrorMagicGifts on Etsy.


What a tough question! A lot will depend on the senior’s personality and interests, as well as the budget you have to work with.

Here are a few ideas to get you started:

Depending on your budget, there are many different options for senior night gifts.


If the senior is a big baseball fan, consider getting them tickets to a professional baseball game.

If they’re not able to attend in person, you could always get them a jersey or ball from their favorite team.

This creative baseball lamp lights up and can be personalized with your player's name and number!

Another option for baseball lovers is to get them a customized jersey number collage covered with pictures of their best memories.

What do you get someone who plays baseball?

customized baseball gifts on Etsy

There are a lot of great gift ideas for baseball players, regardless of their age or level of experience.

For Senior Night in high school or college, consider getting them something to help them with their future career after baseball.

A special, custom keepsake like an engraved baseball make great baseball gifts.

What do you get players for senior night?

A photo collage for your Senior Night player who loves baseball is something he will treasure forever and proudly display at home or in his dorm room.


Senior night is a special event for high school baseball players near the end of their senior year.

It's a time when they can celebrate their time playing together as a team and honor their departing seniors.

One tradition is for the players to give personalized gifts to their seniors.

This can be something simple, like a plaque or an engraved bat, or something more elaborate, like a custom-made jersey or trip away from home.

Whatever the gift, it's a token of appreciation for all the players have done together over the years.

What to get a guy who likes baseball?

A photo collage for your Senior Night player who loves baseball is something he will treasure forever and proudly display at home or in his dorm room.

If your guy likes baseball, then a great way to show him how much you care is by turned one of your shared living spaces into a baseball-themed room (or transform his dorm room!)

If you don't have an extra room to dedicate, don't worry—a small nook or even just a wall can be transformed with the right décor.

Start by hanging up a few vintage baseball posters or photographs. See this Senior Night idea at BlackAndWhiteBonanza on Etsy.

Baseball gifts that celebrate the history of baseball are a great idea for a Father's day gift, coaches gift, or Senior Night gift for your baseball lover.

If you're feeling especially crafty, frame some old baseball cards or create a art piece using old stadium seats.

Then, add in some fun details like team memorabilia, hooks to display his favorite hat and glove, and comfortable seating so he can relax and enjoy his space.

Check out these unique, giant baseball wall murals from

A baseball wall mural is a fun way to show your pride and love for the sport of baseball.

If you're looking for a unique Senior Night gift that your player can use everyday, consider giving him a personalized keychain. Find this at BlackWolfDesigns21 on Etsy.

Bonus: My top 3 Senior Night Gifts For Baseball Players 

Gift 1: Senior Night Photo Collages 

Of course, I have to start with senior night collages! These are my favorite because they use your pictures to create a scrapbook of your athlete’s career on their jersey number. Talk about a personalized keepsake! Your child will love it on senior night AND love it on her dorm room wall! Make it yourself with one of my giant numbers or start your project today by choosing your collage type and size here!

Collage and Wood 36 inch Senior Night Collage

Best Senior Night Gifts 2: Custom T-Shirt Blankets

A close second would be custom t-shirt blankets made from your athlete’s sports t-shirts. These are such a fun way to keep those memories close - and another wonderful addition to a dorm room. There are several vendors available for these, and the most well known is Project Repat. They often have coupon codes for discounted blankets, so plan in advance and avoid paying full price!

Project Repat Blanket

Senior Gift 3:  Make-a-Ball

Rounding out my top 3 is Make-A-Ball. They use athlete photos to create custom baseballs, basketballs, footballs and more! These make great end-of-season gifts as well.  The website says that you can use unlimited photos or texts on your ball!

For the rare three-sport athlete, you could give one of these amazing gifts at the end of each season! But all three make wonderful graduation gifts.

Knock your baseball Senior Night out of the park with these thoughtful gift ideas

Senior Night baseball gifts are a great way to show your favorite baseball player how much you care.

From engraved baseball bat decor to tickets to a game, these gifts will definitely score a home run with any baseball fan.

So get creative and show your favorite baseball fan how much you care on Senior Night.

Is there anything you would add to this list of gifts for baseball fans?


This article may contain affiliate links for the products I recommend. If you purchase after learning about these ideas on my site, I may make a small commission. Thank you for your support!

Back to blog

Leave a comment

Please note, comments need to be approved before they are published.

Affiliate Disclosure

This blog may contain affiliate links. If you click on any of my recommendations and make a purchase, I may make a small commission. Which I will probably use to purchase coffee! 🤩